** CINDERELLA “Heartbreak Station” <i> Mercury</i>
- Share via
Here’s another young hard-rock band with sticky fingers. Cinderella spends most of its third album shoplifting from the Rolling Stones’ catalogue, circa ‘68-72--a far lesser crime, to be sure, than the youthful felonies these Philadelphians committed as purveyors of slick pop-metal on their ’86 debut.
Any band that can achieve a good approximation of the Stones’ raw, cranking classic period--as Cinderella does here-- at least has the validity of a solid bar band. But Cinderella fails to justify and redeem its stylistic thefts by infusing a borrowed sound with a personal perspective.
One exception, “Sick for the Cure,” shows real heart, as leader Tom Keifer captures the tension between soul-sick dejection and joyful release that characterizes some of the Stones’ best stuff.
But most of the songs on “Heartbreak Station” serve up ready-made situations and stock sentiments that come swathed in cliches (it doesn’t help that Keifer, a solid enough singer when he stays within his range, relies mainly on a mangy, upper-register yowl). Yeah, we all need someone we can lean on, but at some point a rock band has to be able to communicate something of its own.
Albums are rated on a scale of one star (poor) to five (a classic).
More to Read
The biggest entertainment stories
Get our big stories about Hollywood, film, television, music, arts, culture and more right in your inbox as soon as they publish.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.